Post by Imonamilkcarton on Dec 12, 2013 12:42:29 GMT
I did a blind test using serval friends and neighbors.I tested PS4 multi plats vs Xbox One multi plats.I used 3 Differnt Tvs,A Vizio 32 inch 3d led tv,a Samsung 42 Oled tv,and a Sony Bravia 50 inch tv.The 3 games Tested was Call of Duty Ghosts,Assiains Creed 4,and Battlefeild 4!(now I also took the time to calibrate all TVs and mostly fixed the extra sharpening in games,but COD Ghosts for Xbox One seems that Activision added their own sharpening filter to game)
I even broke the test groups into 3 groups.Gamers,causals and Hardcore a Gamers/Geeks.The groups didn't know they where grouped like that.
The first group to test and play on all 3 TVs and all 3 multi platform games on both consoles.At the time of playing the groups did not know which console they was playing.Nobody could tell a difference.So out of the casual group none could tell a difference!
So Score so far.
XBOX ONE 0
PS4 0
Next up was the gamers or the bro shooter gamers to test.They played on all 3 Differnt TVs,all 3 Different multi plats and both consoles.This test was a little Differnt them the first.They did not just watch my gameplay of said games.I had them watch my game play and the play the Different versions.We had a Mixed result out of this one.Most couldn't tell a difference in frames rates, graphics and or sound.They picked the picked Xbox One version Of Call of Duty Ghost as the best version,but the rest of the games the same.Call of Duty won because the colors where richer.(now I also took the time to calibrate all TVs and mostly fixed the extra sharpening in games,but COD Ghosts for Xbox One seems that Activision added their own sharpening filter to game)
XBOX ONE 1(COD GHOST)
PS4 0
Next up where the hardcore(these included Xbots and Sony Fanboys)Now these tests was done of the course of serval weeks.I also was amazed that there was One person out of the hardcore gamers who could tell a difference.All the other 6 hardcore gamers couldn't tell the difference no more the causals or the bro shooters!Now I marked theis round up as tie,but we will go into more detail with the one person who could tell a difference with.
XBOX ONE 0
PS4 0
The One person who could tell a difference was only 90% right.Assains Creed 4 stopped his 100% goal!This person also stated that he was a NeOgaf board member.He also said that the alasing was more detected on the Samsung tv then the other 2.He also stated that to his surprise upscaled on the Sony Bravia was not as telling,and that jaggies and color was what give away what.He then went on to say that the issue of every game need 1080p has went out the window with him.He said Neogaf has made 1080p a marketing term for Sony.That 720p COD and Battlefeild 4 where 95% visual equals to there 900p and 1080p counter parts minus Jaggies.He also stated that Ryse at 900p was more impressive then Killzone ShadowFall.He then ask could he play Ryse and I said yes!
I even broke the test groups into 3 groups.Gamers,causals and Hardcore a Gamers/Geeks.The groups didn't know they where grouped like that.
The first group to test and play on all 3 TVs and all 3 multi platform games on both consoles.At the time of playing the groups did not know which console they was playing.Nobody could tell a difference.So out of the casual group none could tell a difference!
So Score so far.
XBOX ONE 0
PS4 0
Next up was the gamers or the bro shooter gamers to test.They played on all 3 Differnt TVs,all 3 Different multi plats and both consoles.This test was a little Differnt them the first.They did not just watch my gameplay of said games.I had them watch my game play and the play the Different versions.We had a Mixed result out of this one.Most couldn't tell a difference in frames rates, graphics and or sound.They picked the picked Xbox One version Of Call of Duty Ghost as the best version,but the rest of the games the same.Call of Duty won because the colors where richer.(now I also took the time to calibrate all TVs and mostly fixed the extra sharpening in games,but COD Ghosts for Xbox One seems that Activision added their own sharpening filter to game)
XBOX ONE 1(COD GHOST)
PS4 0
Next up where the hardcore(these included Xbots and Sony Fanboys)Now these tests was done of the course of serval weeks.I also was amazed that there was One person out of the hardcore gamers who could tell a difference.All the other 6 hardcore gamers couldn't tell the difference no more the causals or the bro shooters!Now I marked theis round up as tie,but we will go into more detail with the one person who could tell a difference with.
XBOX ONE 0
PS4 0
The One person who could tell a difference was only 90% right.Assains Creed 4 stopped his 100% goal!This person also stated that he was a NeOgaf board member.He also said that the alasing was more detected on the Samsung tv then the other 2.He also stated that to his surprise upscaled on the Sony Bravia was not as telling,and that jaggies and color was what give away what.He then went on to say that the issue of every game need 1080p has went out the window with him.He said Neogaf has made 1080p a marketing term for Sony.That 720p COD and Battlefeild 4 where 95% visual equals to there 900p and 1080p counter parts minus Jaggies.He also stated that Ryse at 900p was more impressive then Killzone ShadowFall.He then ask could he play Ryse and I said yes!
